Wednesday 14 November 2012

Poppycock & The Desperate Cognoscenti


I’m a massive fan of Twitter; I like: the updates from official sources of information, whether they be football clubs, newspapers or bus companies, the asides and insights, ranging from the banal to the beatific, from those who make their living in the fields of music (David Gedge; Norman Blake), politics (George Galloway; Nancy Taafe), media (Lee Ryder; Michael Crick) or football (Sami Ameobi; Joey Barton) and the chance to engage in semi-serious social interaction with mates both old and new. One of the surprising benefits of Twitter is the chance to interact with huge numbers of match going ordinary Newcastle United fans, who I don’t know in real life, but who provide reactions, both profound and profane, to events involving our club; often as these events are unfolding in real time. Obviously I filter out shoe-waving zanies, bile-spitting xenophobes and cretinous couch potatoes, but my human bullshit detector is not flawless and the occasional shit storm of stupidity breaks overhead, though that is sometimes unavoidable as Twitter involves a great deal of “thinking aloud,” as we process events in the search for significance.

Through Twitter, I came across one of the most bizarre examples of sporting deceit imaginable on the afternoon of November 4th, when Newcastle drew 1-1 away to Liverpool, when I discovered there are those who engage in the ludicrous pretence of being present at away games, when they’re actually watching them on television or computer in the comfort of their lounge or spare bedroom.

I mentioned last week that I didn’t see much of the game at Anfield because I was watching the FAI Cup Final between Derry City and St. Patrick’s Athletic, but I did engage in some furtive second screening to see how the Twitterati viewed proceedings. When tweeting from a hand held device, the technological source of one’s thoughts is displayed, whether this be Blackberry, HTS or one of the marvellous range of portable gadgets from Apple MacIntosh; consequently, during a game you can tell who is at home, by the lack of reference to an operating platform (am I getting the hang of this jargon?). However, this doesn’t allow for the basic human urge to tell fibs. Post-match, those who had been updating reactions to incidents and events from their phones, as if they were viewing proceedings from the Anfield Road end, suddenly switched devices, taking to PCs and lap-tops to talk us through their journey back from Merseyside.  No doubt the final whistle had been followed almost instantaneously by a decamping up the stairs to “the study” on the pretence of “working on a document for that meeting on Tuesday;” either that or there’s some mighty fine Wifi on Merseyside and all along the M6 and A69. While I can appreciate that some people possess very fast motor cars that can rapidly bring them on a Sunday night all the way from Sandwell to the Sage in time to see Belle & Sebastian, I wonder just who The Desperate Cognoscenti are trying to kid with their shape shifting on-line shite?
 

Perhaps we have seen an epistemological rupture or break, enacted by The Desperate Cognoscenti. Louis Althusser’s mate Gaston Bachelard proposed that the history of science has been replete with epistemological obstacles, which are unconscious structures that were immanent within the realm of the sciences, such as the principles of division between mind and body. According to Bachelard, the history of science has consisted of the formation and establishment of similar epistemological obstacles, which had to be metaphorically torn down to enable thought to progress. This act of cerebral destruction, not deconstruction, is known as an epistemological rupture, where an unconscious obstacle to scientific thought is thoroughly broken away from.  Consequently, as well as accepting as fact the assumption that watching an away game on television or the computer is now not only as valid a way of experiencing the match as being there, The Desperate Cognoscenti effectively state it is possible to claim that the act of viewing any game from the comfort of home is de facto the same as being there, resulting in the right to assume to the need to metaphorically travel 150 miles home afterwards and record presumed events that happen on this mythical journey, even if in reality you’ve only moved up one flight of stairs. It isn’t The Burma Railroad and it isn’t Chairman Mao’s Long March now is it? However, in their eyes, The Desperate Cognoscenti have provided the on-line solution to the seemingly intractable problem of how to know everything about the game, without being there.

The truly stunning thing about the Liverpool game was that Robbie Savage called it right on Match of the Day 2; Coloccini had an absolute disaster of a game. Having spent 75 minutes trying to kick racism out of the game by booting Suarez at every given opportunity, he got as close to him with an attempted stamp as he had done for the goal and had to see red. In retrospect, it was almost a mercy killing; we got a point in a game we could have won, but would have lost if the captain had stayed on. Colo was no better in Bruges; floundering and flapping as he misjudged a dropping ball, in the way he seemed to do every week in the relegation season, as they took the lead following the kind of aimless punt forward Liverpool profited from and Pardew has seeming fallen in love with as a tactic for us. Of course Coloccini was not the only player to make an appalling error of judgement in that game; Krul’s complicity in the second with the kind of slow motion dive Harper has based his career on has been airbrushed from the media and Marveaux’s air shot from inside the six yard box with an empty goal gaping wouldn’t be tolerated in a Sunday morning 5 a side. On the positive side, Anita’s goal and assured performance hinted at his coming of age within the team; let’s hope so.

I realise I’m being daft by seeking to discuss the game itself. The Bruges fixture was clearly not about football for the vast majority of those who made their way over there. Whether you were a jested-hatted zany with 23 on the back of your replica shirt, or a Stone Island attired Bender Squad veteran, affecting the kind of thousand yard stare perfected by Peter Mullen in Tyrannosaur, the whole glee club outing was a glorified stag do, where beer, brawling, balladeering and bad behaviour was the order of the day. However, it must be stated that unlike the Caring Club’s trip down the Durham coastline on the rattler, no trains were trashed, employees assaulted or bogs smeared in shit; the legendary class, dignity and panache of Newcastle’s support was overwhelmingly in evidence for the whole time, or so I’m lead to believe. Unlike The Desperate cognoscenti, I wasn’t there.  

I like a drink, rather too much if I’m honest, but I like football more. If I’d been there, I’d have attended the game totally sober as I don’t like to watch football under the influence as I find it difficult to get a proper perspective on events. Post-match, it’s different; there’s nothing I like to do more than quaff an ale in The Town Wall, while observing The Desperate Cognoscenti in their £400 hi-viz anoraks reinventing themselves as time-served casual icons, swapping bon mots about socks. However, if I’d been in Belgium, I doubt I’d have ruined the memories of seeing my team play by drinking myself to a standstill before kick-off. Obviously I still tweeted that I was on the peeve with Jacques Brel, Plastic Bertrand, Hercules Poirot and Tin Tin, eating moules mariniere and drinking Leffe.

The truly remarkable thing about tweeting from your phone if you’re a supporter of Newcastle United is that you can actually find time in between the torrent of junk emails from the club to register your thoughts. Even during games, I find myself bombarded with automated communications, offering the chance to book executive boxes for home games, or entreating me to buy execrable NUFC branded onesies or the loathsome Howayman outfit. When these arrive during a single goal home defeat to West Ham, where the post Bruges hangovers on the pitch and off it, made us easy pickings for The Hammers, it didn’t do my mood any good. Admittedly we’ve only lost a game and not seen the season disintegrate, as some seek to claim, but it leaves a bad taste in the mouth, especially when I reflect on the fact I’ll probably not see another home game in 2012. I’ll definitely be missing the Swansea and QPR home games, because of Percy Main commitments, as well as things looking dodgy for Wigan (work) and Massive Club citeh (Hibernian v Motherwell was just too tempting).

My interest in local amateur football is the best way I know to get Newcastle United and the emotional upset they cause me out of my head; on Friday I’d seen West Allotment Celtic and Morpeth Town share 8 goals in a sparkling contest at Blue Flames, while the day after that, Percy Main won 4-3 at Wallsend Town. The weekend’s big non-league stories in the region might have been Whitley Bay’s astonishing 8-3 victory over Penrith and West Auckland seeing off Darlington 2-1 with a last minute penalty in the £10 game (where even Mike Amos found the anti-Traveller songs of The Quakers to be “bordering on racism;” does that mean we’ll see anything done about it? In the same way as Stuart Pearce has announced he “trusts” the Serbian football authorities to sort out the fall-out from the England Under 21 game last month, don’t bother to watch this space would be my advice…), but for Percy Main the headline news was the departure of our boss Gareth Allen, who leaves with all good wishes. We have to move on and I did on the Monday night to see Team Northumbria get the better of Guisborough Town (including Jamie Poole, the player who escaped censure for his foul-mouthed, racist tirade aimed at Benfield’s Jordan Lartey back in January) 8-7 on penalties after a 2-2 draw in the Northern League Cup, with the match finally ending at 22.22. At least I got away an hour earlier on Tuesday, when South Shields overcame Alnwick Town 4-2 on a calm, temperate evening. It was the first time I’d been to Filtrona Park in 6 years and I thoroughly enjoyed it.

At the two games listed above, the talk among the crowd was of developments involving two local football figures: firstly, James McClean, who chose not to wear a poppy as the Mackems crashed to their usual defeat at Everton. I’ve no time for McClean, who seems to be this decade’s Keiron Brady without the talent but with more ego. However, I am a pacifist. Consequently, I’ve never worn a red poppy in my life, though I did used to wear white ones when they were briefly available about 20 years back, so I’ll say fair play to McClean for standing up to the unsavoury tide of militarism and the fetishisation of the armed forces, so prevalent among the on-line Tyrannosaur tribute acts, that I find so repugnant. Fight War Not Wars, as Crass said back in the day.
 

And then there’s Mark Clattenburg. Despite the fact he’s been stood down for three successive Premiership fixture cards without an official syllable being uttered regarding the progress of any investigation in to these allegations against him, it seems as if his case may be moving towards a conclusion. The Metropolitan Police have decided not to investigate him any further as “no complaint has been made,” which is legally fairly cut and dried. Of course the lack of a criminal conviction is no guarantee of indemnity from the football authorities, as John Terry can confirm; incidentally, his serious injury on Sunday in the game versus Liverpool meant that the day wasn’t a complete write-off. As bonehead racist moron Gareth Kirkham faces criminal proceedings for his monkey gesture at Stamford Bridge against Manchester United in the game 3 days after Clattenburggate, the FA continue to drag their heels over claims that Clattenburg used “racial” language to John Obi Mikel and Juan Mata. The referee claims Mikel misinterpreted the phrase “I don’t give a monkey’s” and vehemently denies calling Mata “a Spanish twat.” Chelsea FC; fighting racism since October 27th 2012…..

I would like to extend my hand in friendship to Juan Mata and I would hope he has put his other hand in his pocket to help out the club where he started out; Real Oviedo. The Guardian’s Spanish football correspondent Sid Lowe, a journalist of impeccable morals and superb erudition, acting as a counterbalance to the loathsome, preening David Conn-Man and mendacious, prattling Lousie Taylor, spread the case of Real Oviedo’s imminent demise on Twitter. As a way of saving the club, now mired in debt following relegations and boardroom incompetence on a massive level, a cash injection has been sought, not in terms of a fan buy out sadly, but by means of a share issue that runs until November 17th. You can buy shares here and I’d urge you to do so; http://www.realoviedo.es/yosoyelrealoviedo/

The share issue may not be the ideal solution to the problems of this club and others in Spain and the rest of the World, buckling under the weight of debt occasioned by recession and incompetent boards or an effective way forward, but a £10 donation to help keep a club afloat is a decent gesture. Certainly it’s probably less opportunistic than the Ebbsfleet adventure under the auspices of www.myfootballclub.co.uk which I invested £35 in a few years back. Ebbsfleet are still in The Conference and still managed by Liam Daish, but the numbers of investors / subscribers to the project has dropped off markedly. The reason for that is probably far more to do with a lack of emotional and geographical attachment to a club from the road to Tilbury Docks among the initial members of the project; personally I couldn’t even be bothered to go and see a team I was an equal part owner of when they played at Gateshead, much less travel to see them win the FA Trophy at Wembley. It seems churlish to point out that the discredited NUST may have had plenty to say about Plymouth Argyle in the past, but nothing at all regarding Ebbsfleet or Oviedo, but I’ll say it anyway. NUST seem happy to send out almost as many unsolicited emails as the football club do, almost all of them appropriating Bobby Robson’s famous comments about Barcelona at the drop of a hat -:

“What is a club in any case? Not the buildings or the directors or the people who are paid to represent it. It’s not the television contracts, get-out clauses, marketing departments or executive boxes. It’s the noise, the passion, the feeling of belonging, the pride in your city. It’s a small boy clambering up stadium steps for the very first time, gripping his father’s hand, gawping at that hallowed stretch of turf beneath him and, without being able to do a thing about it, falling in love.”

Sadly NUST seem high on romantic idealism, low on tactics and utterly devoid of any grasp of the importance of current, unfolding events. Meanwhile, Oviedo streamed their 1-0 win over Real Madrid C last Sunday (wish I’d seen that instead of the West Ham game) and are rewarding anyone who buys a share with free entry to a game, on production of their share certificate, which looks like the best possible reason to visit Asturias in the future. All together now; we hate Gijon and we hate Gijon. We hate Gijon and we hate Gijon. We hate Gijon and we hate Gijon. We are the Gijon haters.

However, if anyone out there believes I’m being soppy or romantic by my gesture to buy a share in Oviedo, can I just say that I recognise what is far more important in the broader scheme of things, is the success of the General Strike in Spain on Wednesday November 14th. Workers standing together to fight back against austerity and social repression is far more important than how much beer you get down your neck in Belgium or who wore what on their jersey at the weekend; to claim otherwise is pure poppycock…
 

No comments:

Post a Comment