Wednesday, 3 June 2020

Project Solipsism

Fans of Hearts & Sunderland should look away now....

FA Cup: Sunderland goalkeeper Jon McLaughlin becomes ball boy ...

Apologies for the delay in getting this missive out to you. Over the past couple of weeks, the arrogant and contemptuous refusal of the unelected, money and ideology driven demagogues with their hands firmly grasped round the reins of power, to adequately explain and take responsibility for their palpably illegal actions, has meant that while every single day I’ve thought about sharing my thoughts with you, the sands of obfuscatory disinformation have shifted once again, meaning my opinions would have been rendered anachronistic.

You probably expected me to mention Dominic Cummings, or even do an article on the layers of ludicrous lies heaped on his trip to Durham. Equally, the sickening murder of George Floyd and the nauseating, lying response by the racist US state apparatus should be written large in blood red capitals by a better author than I.  However, I decided that debating such topics would be a pointless act; firstly, because I didn’t feel equipped to adequately encapsulate the extent of the misfeasance at the heart of the current British and American governments and secondly, because John Crace of The Guardian says everything that needs to be said in his daily column, which I implore you to read.

Moving back to football, I had hoped to start on this piece on Sunday 24th May, as it was eleven years to the day that Newcastle United were relegated from the Premier League for the first time which, as national footballing authorities had been supposed to submit detailed plans for the future of the domestic game in their country to UEFA by 25th May, seemed to be appropriate in several ways, including the hinted conclusion of the glacially paced takeover by the amoral butchers from the House of Saud, blowsy nicotine addict Amanda Staveley and the elusive philanthropic billionaires, the Reuben Brothers. However, the Premier League’s admirable refusal to provide assent for this sordid gang of ne’er-do-wells to assume control of NUFC, albeit for completely the wrong reasons, means that the whole deal appears almost certain to fail, which has caused a pandemic of cognitive dissonance among the entire NUFC Twitterati, who have declared a cyber pogrom on Hatice Cengiz, whose appeal for justice for her murdered fiancĂ© have been met with contemptuous abuse at every turn. It is sickening behaviour and, as must be pointed out at every turn, certainly not her fault that arguments over broadcasting rights of Premier League games have holed the pirate ship PIF below the waterline.

A perhaps surprising side effect of the vacuum created by the derailed and discredited attempted takeover has been the emergence from underneath rocks of the usual suspects from leafy Ouston and arid Dubai, in a so far unsuccessful attempt to rehabilitate their ruined reputations by getting their gnarled grids and tawdry timepieces all over a series of demotic publicity shots with a startled and slightly revolted Chris Mort, like it’s Baha Beach in 2007 all over again. Instead, the unlikeable lads are emerging, tentatively and shamelessly by turns, from a year of peer-imposed social media lockdown, by means of a regular drip feed of widely-ignored and otherwise derided populist articles and podcasts, claiming the future for NUFC is so radiant as to be indistinguishable from a paradisal afterlife.  Somebody needs to show these lads some love and understanding soon, or they’ll explode from being ignored. Perhaps a few pairs of comfort socks might help.

On Thursday 26th May, the Premier League finally announced that the season would recommence in exactly three weeks, on Thursday 17th June. Fair play to our very own Adonis Brooooth mind; the fella who looks like he lives on fishcake and chips four times a day has expressed his reservations as to whether elite professional athletes will be back in the correct shape in time. I think that’s a question best answered by Jack Grealish, Kyle Walker, Callum Hudson-Odoi, Alexandre Lacazette, Moise Kean, Phil Foden and all the other moneyed transgressors who broke COVIS-19 lockdown laws this past while. However, Broooth’s compassion does stand in sharp relief to the deeply distressing tales of nice guy Rafa endlessly bullying Craig Bellamy, for instance.

Of course, during the long period of silent uncertainty when we didn’t know if English football would embark upon the tortuous processes related to Project Restart, there was the soporific sight of German football effortlessly gliding back into place, albeit with grounds devoid of spectators, stripping the games of any atmosphere. This minor detail wasn’t enough to cool the burning ardour of the Brownshirt Bupastadt Brits: Der Stanabteilung mit Schwein und Hund who tweeted endless moist gusset shots of their unseemly excitement and hazy comprehension of ihre Unzureichendemannschaft  until die Kulturellenaneigner endured a four goal chasing second time out and they went back to self-mythologization as their default pastime: ich war kein Bergmann, ich war kein Maurer, ich habe nicht auf Baustellen gearbeitet nach dem Krieg…


Being serious, despite several positive tests and Troy Deeney slipping his ankle tag to avoid training, the Premier League seems to be heading forwards with the minimum of fuss, the occasional positive test result notwithstanding. Don’t get me wrong; I’d rather they play these two previously postponed PL games, then call the table on a PPG basis, as well as handing the FA Cup to the side who’ve scored the most goals in the competition, in recognition of Newcastle’s superb commitment to attacking football in the first part of the season, but in the elite strata of the game there’s no room for selfishness or sentimentality; sport rules the waves. The dates and times for all games are now in the public domain and the participating clubs have given their assent. Oh, if only this were the case among the professional plankton in the lower depths of the game.

It’s no secret that my Scottish team is Hibernian, but it is a less well known fact that I have more than a passing affection for both Bradford City and Port Vale, who are the two sides I follow in League 2. In the case of Bradford, it was and affection caused by regularly attending games at Valley Parade when I was a student at Leeds University, while Port Vale is more difficult to quantify; I suppose simply enjoying my visits to Burslem where I saw Newcastle win on both occasions, was enough, especially as it contrasts with memories of near death experiences at nearby Stoke City in the League Cup back in 1995. Not only do they both have my affection, they have my total respect after they selflessly abandoned hopes of a play off place by voting to curtail the League 2 season, rather than imperilling the continued existence of their rivals by embarking upon a fiscally ruinous course of events by playing out the rest of the season behind closed doors. It is an example of the kind of sense of responsibility for the sport as a whole that is sadly lacking in League 1.

The top of the table in the third tier is fascinating to behold; while Coventry and Rotherham are rightly being regarded as over the hills and far away, the play off places are incredibly tight. Currently, there is only a single point separating Oxford in third from Wycombe in eighth, with Peterborough holding onto the last play off spot on goal difference from Sunderland and Wycombe. There is, of course, a crucial ace in the pack that Wycombe are delighted to lay down; if PPG is applied to the table, the Chair Boys have a crucial game in hand, which moves them to third and bumps Peterborough out of the play offs entirely. The Mackems, it should be noted, have played 1 more game than their rivals, which means they drop to eighth on that basis.

Remembering the events of early 1998 in the FA Cup, I have little to no sympathy for Stevenage and their imminent relegation from League 2, enabling the infamous radgies of Barrow to return to the Football League after a 48-year hiatus. I have even fewer fellow feelings for Donald Stewart’s mob. If natural justice is applied, they must endure a third successive season in the third tier and Peterborough, though my memory of one wonderful trip to London Road in September 1992 remains undimmed, must sadly accompany them.

For the overwhelming majority of League 1 clubs, including Sunderland if truth be told, the expense of holding games behind closed doors, removing the major income stream of matchday income, is an impossible burden. Cancelling or curtailing the campaign is the only realistic way forward. We’ve come too far to entertain the first option, so the second must be embraced and PPG is the only possible fair way to compile a final table. The sheer length of time it has taken to come to a decision means that it is totally unfeasible to try and schedule up to 10 rounds of ordinary league fixtures and then the play-offs, if we want the season finished before the clocks go back. As a result, the teams in the play-off places should continue the season to a natural conclusion, albeit without fans to see it. Donald Stewart, up to his oxters in debt and sinking fast, has admitted, like so many from Wearside before him, that taking the matter to court without support from Legal Aid is a complete non-starter, though Peterborough’s wannabe DNS Howyeh owner Darragh MacAnthony, always keen to reinforce his Love\Hate persona, has muttered dark thoughts about stepping the argument up to Hutch–Kinahan levels of debate. We shall see, after the EFL constituent divisions hold definitive meetings in the week beginning 8th June.

Mind if you think Peterborough, Stevenage and Sunderland are behaving like spoilt brats, you should see the sickening and selfish plans being tabled by the frighteningly scarified Ann Budge, owner of Heart of Midlothian, for Scottish league reconstruction. For the past 7 seasons, the Scottish game has bumbled along as usual under the current structure of 4 divisions of 12-10-10-10, with Celtic winning it every year of course. Having last kicked a ball in mid-March, the SPFL came together to vote on the season’s end. After a tortuous process blighted by the arrogant selfishness of Rangers FC, who are only 1 year older than the SPFL it should be remembered, the bottom 3 leagues were curtailed, with some important modifications. Firstly, Brechin City were spared the indignity of every previous wooden spoonist by not having to play off against either Kelty Hearts or Brora Rangers to keep a spot in League 2. Secondly, Cove Rangers swapped places with Stranraer and Raith Rovers with poor old Partick Thistle. Thirdly, Dundee United were declared Champions of the Championship, but their replacements weren’t immediately confirmed, as the Premier League went into suspended animation.

Throughout their 8-year existence, Rangers have always adopted the default position that whatever inconveniences Celtic must be ruthlessly pursued. They screamed and cried like bairns with colic to try and prevent Celtic getting their hands on 9 in a row, demanding Neil Doncaster be suspended and hinting at the existence of a weighty dossier of corporate misfeasance that turned into the square root of jack shit in the clear light of day. Consequently, the Premier League was called, the Huns took the huff and Hearts took the tumble to the Championship, finishing four points adrift at the foot of the table, having only won four games all season; two of those against Hibs, I am ashamed to admit…


Being dispassionate, Hearts deserve to be relegated on merit. They are palpably and demonstrably the worst side in the division over a period of 30 games and seven months and nothing can hide that fact. Unfortunately, to the universal derision of Scottish football, other than followers of Partick Thistle, Rangers and possibly the mighty Stranraer, the Grandmother of King William, Worshipful Sister Budge, simply won’t let it go. In the Crazy World of Annie Budge, the restoration of the natural order isn’t the fault of Craig Levein, Austin McPhee, Daniel Stendal or two dozen unmotivated, underperforming players in maroon, it’s all the fault of SPFL that COVID-19 wrecked the season. In the Gorgie dreamworld, the only way to solve all the problems in Scottish football is to reconstruct the league set up in a way that benefits Hearts.  Budge’s proposals are for three divisions of 14, or possibly 16 in the bottom tier if Kelty and Brora are invited on board. Incidentally, that bottom tier will include Stranraer, so quite how Hearts have salvaged the souls of the Stair Park stalwarts isn’t immediately apparent. Partick Thistle seem keen though and that’s about all the positives to be taken from this proposal.

Early indications are that the proposals are doomed to failure; there is absolutely no chance of 15 lower division clubs voting for this farce. For instance, why would Cove Rangers deny themselves promotion? And yet, never rule out the possibility of corruption masquerading as compromise in Scottish football administration, with Neil Doncaster moving the goalposts, by changing the question top flight clubs are being asked. Instead of saying will you agree to a 14-club top division for 2 years? Doncaster has asked the far more nebulous, what will it take you to accept a 14-team top division for, possibly, the next 5 seasons?

In my eyes, it appears Doncaster is angling for a 14-10-10-10 structure, with Brora and Kelty given seats around the campfire. A cynic would suggest that at least a division’s worth of teams will go to the wall, if they’re required to play behind closed doors from 1st August, so any reconstruction will embrace the salient principles of Social Darwinism. However, one thing Budge has done is persuade billionaire philanthropist James Anderson (not the Burnley Lara, incidentally) to have a rake around the back of his sofa and come up with a £2m donation to be spread out equally among all 42 (or perhaps 44) member clubs. Nigh on fifty grand may not even pay for Leigh Griffiths’s latest hair weave, but for the likes of Annan Athletic it’s probably enough to keep their heads above water for the next while, until such time as their average 200 crowds come banging on the door again.

Certainly, were such a state of events to come to pass, I’d regard it as a price worth paying for the devious machinations of the maroon Machiavellis. As regards League 1, there’s no chance I could ever support anything other than PPG as a means to ending the season.



No comments:

Post a Comment