Wednesday, 20 February 2019

To Err Is Human; To Forgive Divine....

There's a noticeable lack of Christian charity about the place whenever Samima Begum is discussed...


I may have mentioned this before, but my first conscious political act was on the night of the General Election on 28th February 1974, when me and Paul “Sten” Stonehouse stood outside the Polling Station at Felling Community Centre chanting “Heath is a cunt,” which I’d still suggest was a slice of prescient analysis for a pair of 9 year olds. Just over 5 years later, on Saturday 28th April 1979, the weekend before Thatcher won her first election, I became an active Socialist when I went on my first Tyneside May Day March. In those days, the turnout on a route that wound from Neville Street behind the station to a mass rally in Exhibition Park rivalled the number of participants for the Durham Big Meeting. The whole experience was inspirational. I’d love to say that was the day I fell in love with the Socialist Party of Great Britain, and other companion parties in the World Socialist Movement, but it wasn’t. That genius move didn’t occur until I arrived at university in September 1983.

However, I met other kids around my age who earnestly hoped for non-violent social change. Consequently, I found myself in the presence of the tribunes of a putative revolutionary scion called the National Union of School Students; a front organisation for the youth wing of the Socialist Workers Party. Needless to say I joined and enjoyed a summer and autumn of youthful class struggle, made even sweeter by our entire branch’s defection from the SWP to Revolution Youth, the International Marxist Group’s Under 5s. I’m still in touch with Avram, Patricia and Peter who I met that day; semi-regularly we have catch ups that include visits to museums, art galleries or the theatre.  I still feel nostalgic for the weekly wise words contained within the covers Socialist Challenge. The cogent support for women’s rights, gay equality and the nationalist population in the Six Counties was so far removed from the crass, oily workerism of the likes of the boiler-suited boors on the tools with Militant.

I’m proud to be a Socialist and I’m more than proud my son is one also. I think his first conscious political act was to take a couple of days off school to demonstrate outside the Civic Centre about the first set of cuts that accompanied the introduction of state endorsed penury, in about 2010 or 2011, when he was a similar age to me at the end of the 70s. Needless to say, these days he’s a member of the Labour Party; almost everyone I’m related to is, even me. Probably that’s why I was so happy to see all those mass walk outs in schools across the country on Friday 15th February, with a whole swathe of teenagers expressing their concern at the future of their planet by the supreme act of defiance enshrined in a withdrawal of their labours. Mind, the world has changed irrevocably; most adults seem to think that what starts with a half day of to wave some flags in solidarity with David Attenborough ends with the bairns in a tent in Raqqa like Samima Begum, bearing a Kalashnikov in one hand and a suckling infant in the other.


When news about Samima’s circumstances and desire to return broke, the response to it was fairly predictable; sombre, posturing rhetoric from politicians hellbent on sweeping all talk of the impending Brexit Nuclear Winter from our screens and tidal waves of incoherent, rambling bloodlust from the haram gammon authoritarian populists. Some want her hung in the street, while others call for her to be beheaded. It’s a sad state of affairs when the vicious, evil Tory government we are yoked under is to the left of a significant strand of public opinion.
We’ll return to the question of Samima’s citizenship and the role of Uncle Tom Javid later, but first I’d like to consider the case of James Gralton; the only Irishman to be barred from the Free State after Partition. Born in 1886, Gralton was a native of Effrinagh, six miles east of Carrick-on-Shannon in the county of Lovely Leitrim.  Reared on a small farm of about twenty-five acres of bad land, Jimmy migrated to the United States in 1909, but returned to Ireland to fight in the Civil War on the Republican side, though he left once more for furr Amerikay after the Treaty Forces prevailed. However, the flowing waters of the dark, mutinous Shannon had him in their thrall and, like a good lad; he came home once more in 1932 to look after his aged mother. Additionally, he had a couple of part-time jobs that reflected his interests; joining the Revolutionary Workers' Group, a predecessor of the Communist Party of Ireland, as well as running a dance hall in Effrinagh where he organised free events and expounded his political views between numbers. These were clericofascist times in Connacht and violent protests against these ideologically pure dances were led by Catholic priests, which culminated in a shooting incident. Following this, on 9th February 1933, Jimmy was arrested, and later deported to the United States of America, on the basis that he was an alien, despite his Irish citizenship. Seemingly, the legality of such actions was not considered relevant when the state decided vengeful repression was the order of the day.

Meanwhile, in the present day, social media drips venom in the form of endless demands for the execution of Shamima Begum; a 19 year old mother and widow. To summarise, in 2015 Shamima left her home in east London with two fellow pupils from Bethnal Green Academy, both of whom subsequently died in western airstrikes. Their journey to Syria via Istanbul was funded by the sale of stolen family jewellery and inspired by ideological brainwashing by a Glaswegian woman, Aqsa Mahmood, who recruited them to what has been described as a jihadi, girl-power subculture. At the time of their departure, the girls were 15. When I attended the May Day March in 1979, I was 14 and three quarters. The British Armed Forces accept recruits who are 16. The average age of Argentinian conscripts who died in the 1982 Malvinas conflict was 17. Bairns; all of them. Bairns who because of circumstance, belief or accident, end up being trained to fire weapons, learning how to kill. It’s wrong, fundamentally wrong. All of it. At least I have always been an advocate of passive resistance, rather than bloodlust. Unlike those who took up arms, for a cause or worse, a government, I have nothing to apologise for. Shamima Begum made a mistake, but she’s no worse than thousands of other young people attracted to military life by the intoxicating sound of musket, fife and drum. And I forgive them all, because they were children.

Forgiveness, as I understand it, is a fundamental part of Christianity; indeed, absolution is a universal feature of the historic churches of Christendom. Putting the parable of the lost sheep and the principle of turning the other cheek to one side, I accept it is fairly unlikely at the minute that Shamima will apologise, with both honest contrition and full understanding, for her acts. Look at it from her point of view; she has developed a belief that Bush and Blair’s illegal war against Islam was part of a strategy that can only be seen as the New Crusades. While the principle reason for the Iraq War was oil, the messianic, fundamental Christianity of Bush and Blair was an obvious influence on their actions. As a child, Shamima would have seen footage of endless air strikes on innocent Muslims. This must have had an effect; combine that with her current location and the fact the West made her a widow before she was old enough to drive and you can understand her reluctance to condemn the cause for which she has fought.  Certainly, I’m not saying I agree with her, but I understand where she’s coming from.

Sajid Javid’s grandstanding act of stripping Shamima of British citizenship, making her effectively stateless, is not only pompous showmanship; it is also both illegal and futile. Quite properly, the European Court of Human Rights will overturn this pitiful piece of nationalistic propaganda. The Government needs to quietly retreat from this farcical position and undo the stupid response to a febrile atmosphere. Let’s get Shamima home and work with her to find out more about ISIL and her adherence to them. She can, and will, be deradicalised and able to take her place as a useful member of society. Frankly, her experiences with Daesh are probably more valuable than a teenage life spent glugging cider and smoking tabs at Howdon Metro Station.

Jimmy Gralton died in Brooklyn in December 1945, nursed through his final illness by his long-time companion Bessie Cronogue from Drumsna, also in Leitrim. It took over 70 years for Jimmy to receive absolution. After a posthumous campaign to clear his name, Michael D Higgins announced at the unveiling of memorial to Jimmy on 3rd September 2016, at Effrinagh on the site where the hall once stood, that the only deportation of an Irishman from Ireland was "wrong and indefensible". The stone edifice tells the story of Gralton’s life as a labour campaigner and was partially funded by the trade union movement.  A cinematic memorial to Jimmy is Ken Loach’s 2014 film Jimmy’s Hall. Let’s hope it doesn’t take 70 years for Samima Begum to be exonerated, pardoned and accepted for standing up for her beliefs and convictionsecause she knew no better.

1 comment:

  1. Nice one Ian...Bill hicks Christian monologue comes to mind...

    ReplyDelete